Speed is Key When Fishing for Muskie in Northern Ontario

"After I netted, measured and released the 40-inch pike, I hit the free spool button, let the lure drop down, and gave it a kiss. Let the summer games begin." —Gord Pyzer

Talk about a big bang collision of positive forces. Within a matter of hours last week, the muskie season opened across all of Northern Ontario, the summer solstice occurred and the Strawberry moon—the last full moon of spring and the first full moon of summer peaked. If you’re a big toothy critter angler, it doesn’t get any better.

Never one to ignore Mother Nature’s signs, I hitched up the horses to the Kingfisher and headed out onto the water like a kid hearing the bell ring on the last day of school. You’d think after doing this for as long as I have, I’d be a little blasé about the opening of muskie season, but trust me, that is not the case.

Pyzer-Speed-Kills-01
Early in the Northern Ontario muskie season, you need to balance the size of your lure with the speed of your retrieve

I also was not going to let bad karma slip into the picture, so when I got to the first fishing spot of the day, I flicked out my lure about ten feet from the boat and reeled it in quickly. The reason I did this, of course, is that it is bad luck to catch a fish on your first cast, so there was no way I was going to let that happen.

With the superstitions out of the way, I finally made a long cast, let my lure sink for a second and started retrieving it back to the boat. Are you ready for this: a solid fish whacked it and I was hooked up on my very first cast. Okay, on my second cast!   After I netted, measured and released the 40-inch pike, I hit the free spool button, let the lure drop down and gave it a kiss. Let the summer games begin. 

Pyzer-Speed-Kills-02

And begin they did as I hooked an even bigger mid-40-inch northern only a dozen or so casts later. It took the treble hook deeply into its mouth, though, so I kept it in the water alongside the boat and released it quickly after I snipped off the hook. Far better to cut it off, than worry about saving a fifty-cent treble and possibly injuring the fish. And then the muskies showed up.

It was one of the best openers that I can remember, but at the same time, not unexpected. A year ago, grandson Liam and I debuted the season with a humongous muskie that ate his bait within an hour of launching the boat. It is the by-product of using smaller lures early in the season. 

Pyzer-Speed-Kills-03
Liam Whetter caught this magnificent muskie in the first hour of the season using a smaller lure that he could retrieve quickly

With muskies and large northern pike, there is a popular theory that bigger is always better. But it isn’t. Now, for sure, the fish love big baits. As a matter of fact, earlier in the week I was fishing favourite pike water and kept a couple of 24-inch northern pike for shore lunch. I actually enjoy eating pike more than walleye, as the flesh is firmer and tastier. But when I was cleaning one of the fish, I noticed a distended stomach.  When I opened it up to see what it had eaten, out popped a foot-long walleye. So my small shore lunch-size pike had swallowed a walleye half its size and still struck my lure.

Pyzer-Speed-Kills-04

You’d think it would be a case for using even bigger baits for trophy toothy critters and it is, if it weren’t for the conflicting problem that you can’t retrieve them as quickly as smaller lures. And that is the critical take away. Early in the Northern Ontario season, it is a careful act of balancing lure size and speed.

Pyzer-Speed-Kills-05
Gord Pyzer caught this northern pike on his second cast of the day highlighting that peak conditions call for fast retrieve speeds

Last week, for example, the water temperature was hovering around 70°F or 21°C, which sits perfectly in the big toothy predators’ wheelhouses. Plus, they’re both coming off the spawn and are hungry. Under these conditions, we’ve found that speed almost always rules over size. Another good indication was that the fish were slamming the bulging single silver bladed/white bucktailed Mepps Muskie Killer that I was throwing mid-way through the retrieve. They weren’t lazily following it in, and then veering away at the side of the boat, as they often do when you cast much bigger lures with more water resistance.

So, remember, early in the season, speed kills.

Fishing in Northern Ontario

About Gord Pyzer

Gord Pyzer is the fishing editor of Outdoor Canada magazine and field editor of In-Fisherman magazine. He is the co-host of the Real Fishing Radio Show and host of Fish Talk With The Doc.

Recommended Articles

Ontario Fly Fishing Hotspots

The Top 10 List

Keystone Muskies

Fishing Tips for Targeting Muskie on Cedar Lake

Pro Fishing Photos

Helping You Take Better Photos of Your Catch

Fishing and Foraging

Add some fresh foods and forage to your fishing adventures!

Hello Summertime Crappies

Crappies have a reputation for being much harder to find and catch in the lazy hazy crazy days of summer

Pleasant Cove Resort

Setting sights on Georgian Bay Northern Pike

Beasts of the Musky East

Eastern Ontario is a hotspot for musky anglers with big waters that hold giant muskies.

Big Bass Bonanza at Birchland Cottages

The perfect location to spend time with your family and enjoy the incredible fishing.

The Tigers of Sunset Country

The most picturesque of all freshwater fish.

Sweeping the Basin

October is a Great Time to Fish for Ontario Crappie

Baits for Brookies

Using Lipless Rattle Baits for Brook Trout

Fishing & Family

5 Reasons Why Fishing With Family Rocks

Northern Pike in Ontario - The Gear You Need

Learn what tools you need to have on board to effectively catch and release Northern Pike

Multi-Species Fly-Fishing

The Top 5 Flies to Have in Your Fly Box.

Smallmouth Bass Destinations

From rivers to lakes, smallmouth bass are found throughout Ontario.

Smallmouth Bass in Sunset Country

It's great to be a smallmouth angler in Sunset Country because of the numbers and size of bass.

Magpie Reservoir

Excellent Drive-to Angling to Hook Big Walleye

Crankin' in Crappies

The Best Techniques You Can Employ This Fall

Adventure Walleye Fishing Lake Nipigon Style

Fishing 411 Television visits Pasha Lake Cabins

Hit The Hard Rock Cafe

Ice fishing for jumbo perch and crappies in Northern Ontario.