The largest island may be referred to as Ghost Island, Devil Island, or the Great Manitou. Next in size are Little Manitou, Calder, Rankin, and Newman Island. Exploring the Islands you'll likely see lots of interesting plant life and of course, a beautiful view of the lake.
Despite their beauty, the islands remain uninhabited to this day. Ontario Parks also warns against overnight camping on the islands due to mysterious and unexplained past occurrences. Many say that the islands are haunted by the Nbising people after starvation broke out and they were forced to flee after battling the Iroquois.
Of course, many have attempted to set up shop on the islands, but none have prevailed. Great Manitou Island once held a hotel and dance hall, which was burned to bits and never replaced. An old aegirine mine was also once part of Newman Island.
If That Isn't Odd Enough
Nbising myths state that Great Manitou Island will speak to you if you paddle too close. Some have described it as water gurgling in and out of the ancient volcanic pipes that the islands are composed of. Many people believe that the 'voices' are warning paddlers to stay away.
See these mysterious islands for yourself looking out from the waterfront by driving Highway 17 west of the city. To get an even closer look, board the Chief Commanda II for the Manitou Island Scenic Cruise.