Get the Inside Scoop

Learn about this expert's favourite places in the Lake Superior National Marine Conservation Area.

It sits at the top Lake Superior like a crown, an area of protected waters that is fully half the size of Lake Ontario, and no one knows it like Thunder Bay-based kayaker Darrell Makin. He and co-author Zach Kruzins literally wrote the book on paddling the island-choked waters of the Lake Superior National Marine Conservation Area when they published their 2012 guidebook.

A person in a sea kayaking paddling in misty waters

Kruzins recently launched Such A Nice Day, an outfitter offering guided sea kayak and voyageur canoe trips around Thunder Bay. Makin has become Parks Canada’s Visitor Experience Product Development Officer. We caught up with Makin for the inside scoop on his favourite places to paddle in the world’s largest freshwater protected area.

What is your favourite day trip? May I provide my daughter’s favourite place on the lake? It’s called Joe Eagle Rock, close to the community of Rossport on the south side of Healy Island. Getting there makes for a beautiful, contemplative day paddle. There’s a host of natural and cultural history present in the area, and the bare rock point is a great place for a chilly dip. Nearby Superior Outfitters offers rentals and guided paddles through the Rossport Islands, which would be an awesome way for people to experience this amazing place. 

Man watching sunset while sitting on beach beside kayaks

What’s your favourite campsite?  It’s tough to come up with just one! I love the campsite at Worthington Bay, part of the Casque Isles hiking trail system. However, perhaps my favourite spot is the landing at Porphyry Island; the site is managed by the Canadian Lighthouses of Lake Superior (CLLS). It’s isolated and beautiful yet also serves as a gathering spot for boaters, has heritage interpretation opportunities offered by CLLS staff, and many options to explore the site, walk up to the light station, and perhaps even climb the tower. Plus, for an added bonus, CLLS volunteers installed a new sauna in 2018.  Membership or donation to the organization is recommended.

Two yellow kayaks in front of a wood fired sauna

Are you willing to share an unknown gem?  To me, the entire Lake Superior NMCA is an unknown gem!  But I love the outer southern shoreline of Talbot Island. Sorry flat-earthers, but you can really sense the curvature of the earth and the overall grandeur of Lake Superior when you look out across the endless expanse of freshwater from this spot.

Do you have a favourite story about this place?  One that stands out is the tale of the keepers of the Lighthouse of Doom. The first lighthouse on Lake Superior’s Canadian shore was constructed on Talbott Island in 1869. Within its initial four years, three lightkeepers perished: two met their demise in attempting to return to mainland at the end of the season, and one, Thomas Lamphier, died while attempting to overwinter at the lightstation with his wife. Legend has it that Lamphier’s wife wrapped his body in canvas and put the corpse in a rock alcove outside the lighthouse. By spring her hair had turned from jet black to ghostly white. With such a tragic track record, the lightstation was promptly closed by the Canadian government.

Beautiful view from a cliff overlooking Lake Superior

What keeps you coming back?  I’m compelled by the land and waterscape to return.  There are so many places to explore, and because there are so many islands the route can be travelled differently countless times. After almost 25 years of paddling the Lake Superior NMCA region, I feel like I’m unravelling a mystery one expedition at a time. As always, I can’t wait to get back out there again this year.  

Two kayaks and a tent on stone beach

To start your own list of highlights, sign up for a guided sea kayak trip in the Lake Superior National Marine Conservation Area with Naturally Superior Adventures. If you are not a paddler, you can explore the area on a sailing tour with Sail Superior

About Conor Mihell

Conor Mihell is an award-winning environmental and adventure travel writer based in Sault Ste. Marie. Read his work in the Globe and Mail, Explore, Cottage Life, Canoe & Kayak, ON Nature, and other magazines and newspapers. He's been a sea kayak guide on Lake Superior for close to 20 years, and has paddled from Sault Ste. Marie to Thunder Bay. 

Recommended Articles

Mattawa River Canoe Trip Guide

Paddle the rugged and historic waterway.

9 Best Day Trips by Canoe and Kayak

Find out where to go and why you need to do this.

Escape the Crowds

How to plan a Lake Superior Provincial Park canoe trip.

Best Lazy Rivers in Ontario

Relax and let the current take you away.

Canoe on Georgian Bay

Everything you need to know.

Kayak & Canoe Sudbury

9 incredible paddling destinations near the City of Lakes.

Bald Eagles, Herons & Moose

Go on a Halfway Lake Provincial Park backcountry adventure.

Paddling Getaways Near North Bay

Discover 7 stunning places to explore by kayak and canoe.

Missinaibi River Canoe Trip

Learn how to plan a canoe trip down this famed wilderness river.

Skip The Crowds

18 Excellent Alternatives to Algonquin Park

Explore Ontario by Paddleboard

Find SUP rentals near you and get out on the water.

The Spanish River

Everything you need to plan your next canoe trip.

Killarney’s Most Beautiful Lakes

10 lakes you need to book a campsite on.

Top 10 Easy Canoe Trips

Go guided and learn canoe and camping skills in Northern Ontario.

Get On The Water

Ontario paddling events for canoeists, kayakers, SUPers, and rafters in 2024.

paddle the french

A Canadian Heritage River.

Paddle with Your pup

5 Insta-worthy places to go.

The Best Canoe Tripping in Ontario

Clear your summer schedule for a trip along the Path of the Paddle.

Spectacular Rivers

11 easy day trips for canoes, kayaks and SUPs.

Canoe & Kayak Trips in Ontario

Learn how to plan your next paddling day trip or overnight here.